Filed under: A Bit Of Inspiration, Advertising, AI, Attitude & Aptitude, Brand, Brand Suicide, Communication Strategy, Consultants, Creative Development, Creativity, Culture, Delusion, Effectiveness, Efficiency, Technology
I saw this article with Cindy Rose – the WPP Global CEO – in industry publication, Adweek recently. And while a lot of what she said was the same stuff that a lot of industry CEO’s say, there was one bit that particularly grinned my gears.
Have a read:

Yeah … let’s look at the art of translation and research as a functional, repetitive task and conveniently ignore how important context, environment, body language and nuanced understanding/expression is in developing highly effective creativity, communication and brand value.
No offense, but anyone who chooses to spend millions of dollars executing what bots/agents – talking to other bots/agents – tells them to do, is not only outsourcing their responsibility, but also destroying their credibility.
As someone who has lived and worked in a double-digit amount of countries, I’ve seen firsthand the damage – and failure – caused by companies adopting a formulaic, efficiency-first approach towards research and translation. The result being – at best – the work feels about people more than for people. And at worst – actively alienating audiences rather than reflecting local nuances.
Look, I appreciate her acknowledgement of human talent being important in craft and storytelling. And I am a big fan of what AI can do for our industry – believing it can add a lot of value to us creatively and commercially. Plus I can only imagine how incredibly hard it must be to run a huge, global organisation. [I should point out that I don’t know Cindy Rose and have only heard positive things plus I appreciate her comments are similar to what many organisations are doing/thinking beyond just advertising]
However, when we see the quality of ingredients that crucially inform our understanding and delivery of creativity as ‘inefficiencies’ … then we’re not only complicit in commoditising our own industry, it could be suggested that we don’t understand how – or what it takes – to deliver excellence either. And that can be said for any company who demands this – be it from their agencies, people or suppliers.
Frustrating.
